8 Comments
User's avatar
sdonohue1632's avatar

So far, so good. Wonderful to have an objective definition of a 'people' and of Zionism. And the etymology of 'Jew' provided much clarity. Thank you.

Expand full comment
Matt Polani's avatar

Awaiting next installment

Expand full comment
Elizabeth S.'s avatar

Really appreciate your concise writing and the clarity you provide. Eagerly awaiting each new installment.

Expand full comment
Larry935613's avatar

This peace agreement discussion , while intelligently stated, is just an academic exercise in an unrealistic goal.

Anyone who believes there can be peace with the sub human savages in Gaza is unintentionally arguing for Israel to have more of their citizens murdered , raped and terrorized.

For those of you not in Israel , do you want to live next door or across the street from someone who tells the neighborhood they’re going to slaughter you first chance they get.

Someone who showed up at my front door threatening me of my family would get a full clip of 223 in them.

Yet you expect Israelis to live with this.

All this discussion reminds me of someone in the stages of grief that can’t get out of the denial state and more to anger and rage.

The only way for Israel to achieve peace is to kill so many of these animals that the rest want to get the fuck out of there as fast as they can.

Every time the Israelis have made concessions to them thinking it would help achieve peace has moved them one step closer to the catastrophe of 10/7. The decision to vacate Gaza was the icing on the cake of stupidity and must be fixed.

Now is not the time to talk or speculate about peace with this death cult . There is going to be no peace. Israel will either destroy them or be destroyed

It’s time to face reality and stop living in this fantasy world of discussing peace .

Expand full comment
Mr. Ala's avatar

I am going to answer your title rather than your essay, which I have read but it’s a bit elementary for me.

There is a lot of evidence that Jews can’t ever get what they want—secure peaceful coexistence—in a peace treaty.

They would be well advised to change it up. Perhaps, a la Trump, to go bigger, but in any case to do something different.

Expand full comment
Daniel Rubenstein's avatar

Thank you for reading.

Expand full comment
Pool Westbury's avatar

Is this history written in the Bible? Dont we have pretty good historical records (old copies of the new treatment, old testament, archeological evidence, etc) to price the history of the Jews is real?

I am waiting for a grave in Egypt that contains a papyrus documenting the Jews in Egypt.

Expand full comment
rc4797's avatar

LOL

Expand full comment